Capella Grenadine
ConcreteRiver
Setup: Recoil w/ flavor barrel, Dual 15 wrap 26g 3mm Nifethal 70 coils @.13 ohms. 60w power, 450F temp limit. Full Cotton Wicks.
Testing: CAP Grenadine, 2 and 4%, 60/40 VG/PG, Steeped 6 days.
Flavor Description: Nightmare cherry. There is some syrupy cheap grenadine sweetness in there, but the first thing you notice is a face full of those weird, harsh, gasoline or plastic off notes that are depressingly common from cherry flavors. Good grenadine is basically pomegranate syrup, and I can't really taste anything resembling pomegranates. Tastes more like bright red maraschino cherry syrup. No real tartness in here, more of a chalky artifical cherry candy sweetness. Personally I'd give it a pass, but if you are going to use it I'd keep it under 3% to limit some of those off-notes.
Inhale is sharp and bitter from those medicinal plastic off notes. There's a syrupy sweetness underneath, but it just drags the inhale to full on cough syrup. Medium density, but pretty harsh. Exhale has a whole lot of those off-notes right up. Cheap plastic off-gassing, gasoline, bitter florals. Some candy cherry sweetness comes out in the back end. Really light tartness that you'd expect from a decent grenadine, but a whole lot closer to a chalky cherry candy. There is some syrupy sweetness in there, but those off-notes come roaring back in on the tail end of the exhale, with a lingering bitter plastic taste. Medium density, but the throat hit is kind of hellacious.
Off-flavors: Really prominent bitter, floral gasoline and plastic.
Throat Hit: Harsh.
Uses & Pairings: Really, I don't think this is the best option for any mix. This doesn't taste a lot like pomegranate syrup, so I'd skip all of the realistic grenadine applications.
This is gnarly, even for lowered cherry standards. I wouldn't use it anywhere you wanted maraschino cherries either.
Notes: Concentration testing, this is less bad at lower percentages. At 1% I still get a helping of off notes, but they aren't particularly intense. Underlying sweet artificial cherry is pretty weak though. 2% is a little fuller. I'm still getting off flavors, but the sweetness is a little clearer. 3% has a decent-ish sweetness to it and the off-notes aren't that much worse than 2%. 4% has really intense off notes. 5% is pretty much unvapable with those off flavors getting extremely bitter.
FA Pomegranate isn't perfect but that and some sweetener would probably be my best bet on a grenadine that tasted like a pomegranate was involved at some point.
Second Opinions: Hey, some people don't hate this?
I don't know, people seem to dig this on ECX. 5 star average with 5 reviews.
Curses to /u/ID10-T for suggesting this.